Case Studies

Six deals, start to finish

Three sale types, six outcomes. The same auction can hand you a clean flip, a buried lien, a quick 20% return, or a deed for pennies on the dollar — and the difference is almost always what the research found before the gavel fell.

Non-Judicial — mortgage foreclosure. No redemption, immediate title, but senior liens survive.
Judicial In-Rem — court-ordered tax sale. 60-day owner-only redemption; refund only, no premium.
Sheriff’s Levy — tax-lien sale. 12-month redemption at 20%.

Non-Judicial — the same list, two very different deals

Non-Judicial · Mortgage Foreclosure
The Clean Flip
Profit
The setup

A 3-bed brick ranch in a stable Macon neighborhood comes up for non-judicial foreclosure. On paper it looks like a dozen others on the list.

What our research found

Chain of title clean back to the current security deed. No senior mortgage, no IRS or federal tax lien, no judgments. Title risk: LOW. The foreclosing firm reliably proceeds.

The deal math

Estimated after-repair value sat comfortably above the recorded balance; only light cosmetic rehab needed. The recommended max bid left a healthy margin.

At auction

The investor bid within the recommended max and won — taking immediate title, because non-judicial sales carry no redemption period.

The lesson

When the title is clean, a non-judicial sale is the fastest path to a deed. The research is what tells you it’s actually clean.

Non-Judicial · Mortgage Foreclosure
The Inherited Lien
Avoided loss
The setup

A larger home on the same list draws a crowd — the recorded debt looks like a steal against the home’s value.

What our research found

Two problems. A recorded IRS federal tax lien against the owner, and a second security deed. The foreclosure was on the second-position deed — so the senior mortgage and the federal lien would survive the sale and follow the buyer. Title risk: high. Recommendation: do not bid.

The deal math

Add the surviving senior debt to the winning bid and the “steal” was actually above the home’s value.

At auction

A bidder without research saw only the low apparent entry price, won — and inherited tens of thousands in senior liens. The bargain became a loss. Our member passed.

The lesson

The hammer price is not the cost. On a non-judicial sale, senior liens survive — and the only way to know is to research the title before you raise your hand.

Judicial In-Rem — redeemed vs. kept

Judicial In-Rem · Tax Sale
The Redemption Refund
Redeemed — refund
The setup

A court-ordered in-rem tax sale. The investor wins the property for not much more than the back taxes owed.

What our research found

Clean court order; taxes and parcel confirmed. In-rem sales carry a 60-day right of redemption for the owner of record only — and it pays no premium: a redeeming owner simply triggers a refund of the winning bid. This owner had active family.

The deal math

Worst case: the owner redeems and the investor gets the bid refunded — two months of tied-up capital, nothing earned. Best case: keep a property bought for back taxes. That math only works if you actually want the house.

At auction & after

Within the 60 days, the owner’s family redeemed — and the investor received a refund of the bid, nothing more. Under O.C.G.A. § 48-4-81 an in-rem redemption pays the investor no premium.

The lesson

Know which sale type pays you to lose. On a sheriff’s levy, redemption is a 20% yield; on a judicial in-rem it’s only your money back — so bid an in-rem only on a property you’d be happy to own.

Judicial In-Rem · Tax Sale
The 60-Day Wait
Kept the property
The setup

Another in-rem sale, similar profile — won near the tax amount.

What our research found

The owner was deceased and the estate inactive; redemption looked unlikely, but the 60-day clock still had to run. In-rem foreclosure clears most prior claims.

The deal math

If no one redeems, the investor finalizes and holds a property for a tax-sale basis far below market value.

At auction & after

The 60 days passed with no redemption. The investor finalized and took title.

The lesson

The short, court-backed in-rem window makes it the most reliable path from tax sale to ownership — when the research says redemption is unlikely.

Sheriff’s Levy — the patient lien play

Sheriff’s Levy · Tax-Lien Sale
The Patient 20%
Redeemed — 20%
The setup

A sheriff’s-levy (Fi Fa) sale. The investor buys a tax lien — not the property — for the back taxes.

What our research found

A 12-month right of redemption at 20%. The owner was active and the home occupied — redemption likely.

The deal math

If redeemed: 20% return over up to a year. If not: the path opens to foreclosing the redemption and taking the deed.

At auction & after

Around month nine, the owner redeemed — paying the lien plus 20%.

The lesson

Sheriff’s levy is a patient lien/yield play first. The 20% is the base case; ownership is the upside.

Sheriff’s Levy · Tax-Lien Sale
From Lien to Deed
Took the deed
The setup

Another levy purchase at a deep discount — back taxes on a vacant property.

What our research found

The owner was unreachable and the property abandoned — redemption unlikely. We mapped the 12-month clock and the steps to bar the right of redemption.

The deal math

Hold the lien 12 months; if no redemption, foreclose the redemption right and take the deed for a fraction of value.

At auction & after

Twelve months passed with no redemption. The investor barred the redemption and took title — a property acquired for pennies on the dollar.

The lesson

The longest game pays the biggest discount. When the research says redemption won’t happen, a sheriff’s-levy lien can convert into ownership at the deepest basis at the auction.

Get on the early-access list

Be first when First Tuesday Report opens for the July 7 auction. We’ll send a full sample report so you can judge the depth yourself.

Request early access →

🔒 Members: the full Deal Playbook

Premium members get seven of these as real, property-specific walkthroughs — the actual title research, the numbers, the auction result, and what the investor did next.

Preview the Deal Playbook →
Representative examples based on real Bibb County auction dynamics and outcomes. Property details are anonymized and figures are illustrative — not a prediction of any specific result, and not legal or investment advice. Consult a licensed Georgia attorney before bidding.
← Back to home